The Economic “Benefits” of Immigration: Importing A Haystack To Find a Needle

USnews.com recently featured a report titled “Immigration and Economics: By the Numbers.” The article is chock full of gushing praise for immigrant entrepreneurs, claiming that they “enhance productivity and create jobs for Americans and visa-holders alike.” And it cites a study commissioned by Carbonite, a Boston-area software company founded by former IBM executive, and Guyanese immigrant, Mohammed Ali. That study found “that 40 percent of Fortune 500 companies were founded by immigrants or the children of immigrants. And more than half of U.S. startups valued at $1 billion or more…were started by immigrants.”

But, like most mainstream media reporting on the costs of immigration, the U.S. News piece has it all backwards. Most companies aren’t started by a single individual. So it is more than likely that nearly all of the cited businesses would have gotten off the ground and flourished, even without the immigrant who happened to be part of the founding group. More importantly, however, immigrants don’t drive the U.S. economy. America’s enormous, flexible, and resilient economy drives immigration to the United States.

People fleeing civil strife see economic freedom as the ultimate protection against oppression. Individuals who immigrate to the U.S. seeking better life often find that building a business gives them control over their economic destiny in a way that was impossible in their old country. And foreign entrepreneurs don’t immigrate to countries with onerous requirements for starting up businesses. Instead they go where they can make the most of their talent and capital.

That’s why the U.S. has always had a large number of immigrants in the ranks of its successful business people. But that is a measure of how good the United States is for immigrants with business aspirations. It is not necessarily a measure of how good immigration is for the United States.

By Matt O’Brien for Immigration Reform.com
Read Full Article HERE

Share this post

Post Comment